Election supervisor: Werner Koch
Announced end of election: 2006-11-30
Actual time election ended: Fri Dec 1 03:05:37 2006
Private election (1231 authorized voters)
Actual votes cast: 199
Number of winning choices: 1  (Election actually has 1 winner)
Condorcet completion rule: Beatpath/Schulze/CSSD

Election description

Please keep in mind that a logo needs to be clear and not too detailed. It should be as simple as possible (but not simpler). There is no need that the name GnuPG is part of the logo as a logo represents something and should not explain it. It is of course no problem if the name is in it or even be an important part of it.

As we can't know whether the latter will be true for the winning design, we just assume that for now and sort it out later. Same goes for copyright assignment of the logo and such. In case the winner can't fulfil the requirements, I will ask you again for a vote.

Note, that the submissions should all be considered drafts. What we want to select is the basic design; colors and texts are still subject to change. You may click on each name to see the logos or go to the overview. Rate the logos you like and enter "no opinion" for the others.

Ranking of the choices

1. 6 Thomas Wittek  (Condorcet winner: wins contests with all other choices)
2. 30 Robbie Tingey  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 105–48
3. 24 Michel Blinn  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 101–49, loses to 30 Robbie Tingey by 72–71
4. 1 Tobias Dühr  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 102–41, loses to 24 Michel Blinn by 72–69
5. 9 Daniel Huber  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 109–38, loses to 1 Tobias Dühr by 74–62
6. 23 Daniel Jackler  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 115–31, loses to 9 Daniel Huber by 73–51
7. 19 Andrey Alekseev and Sergey Lukyanov  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 112–33, loses to 23 Daniel Jackler by 58–51
8. 18b (with red shield)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 115–27, loses to 19 Andrey Alekseev and Sergey Lukyanov by 50–46
9. 7 Nico Bauer  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 122–21, loses to 18b (with red shield) by 53–48
10. 15a Dima Kalinin (keyring)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 118–19, loses to 7 Nico Bauer by 53–51
11. 20 Andreas Konietzny (any of the variants)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 118–22, loses to 15a Dima Kalinin (keyring) by 54–44
12. 14 Christian Javier ALVAREZ de TOLEDO  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 120–15, loses to 20 Andreas Konietzny (any of the variants) by 47–42
13. 18d (yellow key)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 124–19, loses to 14 Christian Javier ALVAREZ de TOLEDO by 48–42
14. 22 Ruud Schellekens  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 124–25, loses to 18d (yellow key) by 45–44
15. 28 Benjamin Kirschner  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 125–14, loses to 22 Ruud Schellekens by 47–40
16. 18c (outlines gnu)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 124–18, loses to 28 Benjamin Kirschner by 47–32
17. 29a Arnfinn Sarau (key)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 127–17, loses to 18c (outlines gnu) by 46–45
18. 31 Frederic Martin  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 112–25, loses to 29a Arnfinn Sarau (key) by 40–37
19. 16 Roberto A. Foglietta  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 133–11, loses to 31 Frederic Martin by 41–36
20. 2 Ryan Malayter  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 120–22, loses to 16 Roberto A. Foglietta by 43–41
21. 27 Alex Butin  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 118–19, loses to 2 Ryan Malayter by 44–42
22. Tied:
13 Tobias Kohler  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 125–12, loses to 27 Alex Butin by 42–40
17 Hale Yigit  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 129–14, loses to 27 Alex Butin by 39–35
24. 26 Duccio Lunari  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 125–18, loses to 17 Hale Yigit by 40–34
25. 15b (safe)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 119–14, loses to 26 Duccio Lunari by 39–37
26. 10 Igor Gombos  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 129–7, loses to 15b (safe) by 40–34
27. 18a Tri Seprian Damayanto (jumping gnu)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 122–14, loses to 10 Igor Gombos by 36–32
28. 21b (any of the two tree designs)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 120–15, loses to 18a Tri Seprian Damayanto (jumping gnu) by 35–34
29. 11 Thomas Kear  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 130–8, loses to 21b (any of the two tree designs) by 39–37
30. 8 Alexander Klemisch  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 126–10, loses to 11 Thomas Kear by 42–38
31. 5a Andre Piewak (star)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 127–10, loses to 8 Alexander Klemisch by 38–35
32. 15c (lock)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 126–4, loses to 5a Andre Piewak (star) by 42–33
33. 21a Chekmarjov Evgeniy (bullhorn)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 128–11, loses to 15c (lock) by 35–29
34. 25 Juraj Dusík  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 128–10, loses to 21a Chekmarjov Evgeniy (bullhorn) by 35–28
35. 29b (horns)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 130–3, loses to 25 Juraj Dusík by 29–22
36. 4 Mica Mijatovic  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 128–10, loses to 29b (horns) by 32–29
37. Tied:
5c (green cross with letter)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 129–9, loses to 4 Mica Mijatovic by 35–28
12 Igor Pryachin  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 130–8, loses to 4 Mica Mijatovic by 31–30
39. 5b (green cross)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 130–6, loses to 5c (green cross with letter) by 23–20
40. 3a Randy Burns (first one)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 131–6, loses to 5b (green cross) by 28–25
41. 3b (second one)  loses to 6 Thomas Wittek by 131–6, loses to 3a Randy Burns (first one) by 22–14

Election result details

Preference matrix

The following table shows the results of all pairwise contests between two choices. Each entry shows the number of ballots on which one choice was preferred to another choice.

  1.2.3.4.5.6.7.8.9.10.11.12.13.14.15.16.17.18.19.20.21.22.23.24.25.26.27.28.29.30.31.32.33.34.35.36.37.38.39.40.41.
1. 6 Thomas Wittek   -105101102109115112115122118118120124124125124127112133120118125129125119129122120130126127126128128130128129130130131131
2. 30 Robbie Tingey   48-72656975758381758587898287908981909483908890859091839592899095959698931009899100
3. 24 Michel Blinn   4971-7266847779818184898985828689849188909293929090879091909392949594969599989897
4. 1 Tobias Dühr   416969-74757479838178858288858884848888858991868287909093919191949393969498100101101
5. 9 Daniel Huber   38676262-737271677181847982787885778583858285868584818486878684879389939695979594
6. 23 Daniel Jackler   3148415651-5858685957656665626971637276687373726873666978787074757978827778808183
7. 19 Andrey Alekseev and Sergey Lukyanov   335043494851-50585654575863556064546366556063636358625764646064636667706867696971
8. 18b (with red shield)   27363342435046-535054515454515856525460555557575059515160595557565963636065616362
9. 7 Nico Bauer   2146394147494748-5351595660576158586259565664585663595864676864666671707466787273
10. 15a Dima Kalinin (keyring)   194236444753435051-54585860576059545861585755565262606364586659656870697168717071
11. 20 Andreas Konietzny (any of the variants)   22373139424746445244-475150515758545461545856535461555261626158616167656768667171
12. 14 Christian Javier ALVAREZ de TOLEDO   1530273333463841413642-4846464947445151484948484151534748515550515354605761626363
13. 18d (yellow key)   193324373739383343404342-45424048474652495152484453414257494950495254545457566058
14. 22 Ruud Schellekens   25413636313832444536454644-474841464752475249484352534855544751515755605354595861
15. 28 Benjamin Kirschner   1433253136393937383438424340-4741444549464448444449484051515148455250565657565859
16. 18c (outlines gnu)   183025323337312731363540444532-46454346434343433941314148434543454247505255545351
17. 29a Arnfinn Sarau (key)   17283034253233364435404042363945-404050414144373846444253444546444849525249565254
18. 31 Frederic Martin   2532273734323739394140404036364237-4145424042404248464046484544474643504753505251
19. 16 Roberto A. Foglietta   112825262636273630323630413535423936-43374039363240413946394337424245454446495050
20. 2 Ryan Malayter   22262824313334383432384242413743363841-444142424544444249464844474250525052555353
21. 27 Alex Butin   1930212628312528363427363637303239363942-4239334042393743444740404344494647504747
22. 13 Tobias Kohler   122522262934283329353734383535383740364140-36343838414247434642434247555058545355
23. 17 Hale Yigit   14312627313925332937384139393535413636423536-403840384047444642414342535051545352
24. 26 Duccio Lunari   1829233123292432313735363633363638373642363434-3942394050414543414347504850535149
25. 15b (safe)   142721282731243133233439434236384139414034383937-40384044424335454347504647484545
26. 10 Igor Gombos   7251926233131251830303635333037333635403438383034-363739394341394443464646514849
27. 18a Tri Seprian Damayanto (jumping gnu)   1425222227322526263132283633303437343538343333313332-3540393838373532444244434344
28. 21b (any of the two tree designs)   152616242729302734243131363432343836343937353936273634-39363730324040444044414645
29. 11 Thomas Kear   8221520222626262830333433333031293237403231342834363337-424145373740444445474950
30. 8 Alexander Klemisch   1027192420282729193028363334303237333637343531373431313438-3837384242414443484549
31. 5a Andre Piewak (star)   102519242232283225283232373430373532343833333435363440333835-42354443413642374448
32. 15c (lock)   4181113232517232115262628272427272928322829282411282734293133-353031383637393738
33. 21a Chekmarjov Evgeniy (bullhorn)   1117152019262225262024263228283129282535322930272532332936323229-3535413740414242
34. 25 Juraj Dusík   101511181418192422151925262017252625233522302623242630243430302728-29343536373537
35. 29b (horns)   314617151213111212132218201617192119211719201316192220272429222322-323030333028
36. 4 Mica Mijatovic   1016151912202221191721253020212622242926232525222526272728302932252929-3531352832
37. 5c (green cross with letter)   91918191321192417192426231920242124262823242621262727232927232924272728-31233535
38. 12 Igor Pryachin   8191417111819232318172127192224222221252316232026232624232627262228293031-333234
39. 5b (green cross)   61313148181719111721211817161918212221201920172120231826181826192223252029-2831
40. 3a Randy Burns (first one)   6131210915162011151620201613191714131617201614221722192122222421212129202525-22
41. 3b (second one)   613138121514191216172019171421181616141920191723192117201919242220222818252114-

The presence of a green entry below the diagonal (and a corresponding red one above) means that a preference was ignored because it conflicted with other, stronger preferences.


Note, that this page is a copy of the original page with Java script features removed to present a static version. We thank Andrew Myers for setting up this great service.